« Religious Education | Main | Kurtz Provokes Thoughts »

December 18, 2003

The Passion according to Tolkien

From Godspy


The heroes of The Lord Of the Rings who choose death mysteriously, yet unmistakably, increase in reality. This is the central paradox of the mystical life: diminishment in natural being is not necessarily a diminshment of Reality, but is rather often accompanied by a profound intensification of life presence. One thinks of the elderly, or the sick, who, through acceptance of fate, have made it their own and are lit up from within with a holy presence.

Tolkien and the Gift of Mortality

Clearly, mortality is at the heart of this story. The subject has become a hot topic today, with Leon Kass and other “mortalists” arguing against a research culture that sees death and aging merely as foes to be overcome. If medicine succeeds in making man immortal, or even much longer-lived, the mortalists argue, much that makes human life worthwhile will be lost. Kass has used the wisdom of such ancient authors as Homer to illustrate his vision of mortality’s benefits. In The Lord of the Rings, Tolkien makes a Christian case for the same claim. In Tolkien’s world, immortality and long life lead even the noblest creatures to a spiritual dead end, or to outright corruption.

THERE, Mark Shea, who claims of the Trilogy:

"The Holy Father has seen all three films and pronounces them 'way cool'", said Navarro-Valls. "Barb Nicolosi is hereby commanded to recant and renounce her grievous error. Oh, and Amy Welborn was described by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith as 'insufficiently enthused'".

I think two blog entries and the fact that my son has already seen the movie twice should cover me. I do think.

Posted by Amy Welborn | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/316712

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Passion according to Tolkien:

Comments

Oh yeah!

Posted by: Steve at Dec 18, 2003 11:02:17 PM

I had trouble with the First Things link in Amy's post. This one seems to work.

http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft0311/opinion/mathie.html

Posted by: Gray Eminence at Dec 19, 2003 1:57:51 PM

Interestingly, for all that’s been said of how irreligious the screenwriters are, a scene they composited for FOTR the movie echoes very nicely a point from the First Things article:

Saruman: Embrace the power of the Ring or embrace your own destruction... (Gandalf leaps onto a great eagle and escapes) So, you have chosen death.

Posted by: Gray Eminence at Dec 19, 2003 2:14:21 PM

Amy, don't sweat it. Read Jonathan Last for what I think is the best review so far.

My feeling is that Jackson lost control of this thing about 2/3 of the way through The Two Towers. The pacing from that point right through ROTK has been inconsistent and distracting. Some of the characters reduced to the role of grotesques, many other dropped or ignored. Surprisingly unsatisfying given the power of the first film....

Posted by: John Farrell at Dec 19, 2003 4:38:37 PM

Post a comment