« DCF documents | Main | From another alternative NY paper »

March 04, 2005

Who is Matt Taibbi

Apparently, he's not twelve. Apparently he's an actual journalist who appears to be an adult.

Could have fooled me. Could have fooled the world, judging from his piece in the NYPress: The 52 Funniest Things About The Upcoming Death of The Pope

HAH! HAH!

52.Pope pisses himself just before the end; gets all over nurse.

51.After death, saggy, furry tits of dead Pope begin inexorable process of melting away into nothingness, like coldest of Sno-cones under faintest of suns.

50.Pope survives just long enough to be acquired by Isiah Thomas for Stephon Marbury, 2005 #1 pick and cash considerations. "We feel like we've made ourselves younger and more competitive," Thomas says.

49.After beating for the last time, Pope's heart sits there like a piece of hamburger.

48.Whole world waiting until the last minute for a sudden improvement of his condition. Long lines of girls in the Philippines kneeling and praying. Catholics everywhere with ears pressed to radios, transfixed. Pope gives one last groan, spits, dies.

47.Upon death, Pope's face frozen in sickening smile, eyes wide open and teeth exposed, like a baboon.

46.Beetles eating Pope's dead brains.

This is pathological. It's insane. It's evidence of a mind so distant from reality, so shut off from basic human feeling that one wonders why they're letting him have access to a computer, instead of keeping him locked up, counting his toes.

Here's the thing, my friends: gripe all you want about the bad old conservative pope, the repression and oppression he supposedly represents, his legacy of "traditionalism" that is supposedly such a bad thing...here's the alternative. Here are his enemies, those who despise him the most.

Dig those values. Dig that worldview. Live it. Love it. It's yours, all yours.

(Note - I'm having a terrible time getting these pages to load. Good luck to you. Full text of article is below. Sue me NYPress, I really don't care.)

45.Pope departs Earth at a time when Hitch is top-grossing movie in the world.

44.Gurgling sound during embalming process; real fluids in dead Pope's body sucked out into jars.

43.POV Dead Pope: Last glimpse of overcast Italian sky as coffin lid closes for last time.

42.Get used to that quiet sound.

41.Humming old Polish folk song in there. That kills three minutes.

40.Humming it again, this time getting the words right. Another three minutes.

39.Can't move. Can't reach penis.

38.Somebody taking my job. My job!

37.Getting a little stuffy.

36.Naming all the different types of fish. Flounder, halibut, perch, goldfish, basking shark...no, do the sharks separately...really stuffy in here, gar, swordfish, manta ray, eels... No, don't think about eels. Eels are scary. Boy, is it dark in here. Four minutes gone by.

35.Doctor applies fingers to neck to check expiring Pope's pulse. Pope's ear falls off.

34.In heaven, Pope keeps wrapping cars around telephone poles.

33.Silverfish pops out of dead Pope's vestment for a moment, immediately ducks back in.

32.Priest who administers last rites to Pope excitedly calls mother afterward to tell her how well it went.

31.Dead Pope, still with baboon face, wheeled through corridors of Gemelli Polyclinic in Rome, learns answer to Great Mystery.

30.Michael Jackson too broke to buy Pope's bones.

29.New Pope inevitably ambitious cleric burning with earthly vigor and secret desire to undo dead Pope's legacy.

28.Bears everywhere shitting in woods.

27.We'll never get to hear his hilarious post-tracheotomy rendition of "Come on Eileen."

26.Pope recovers and survives until 2009; New York Press columnist Matt Taibbi beheaded by passing garbage truck, March 2, 2005.

25.LexisNexis search on phrase "the inner workings of the Vatican are shrouded in mystery" temporarily crashes system; Eric Alterman unable to search for press references to "What Liberal Media?" for 37 consecutive hours.

24.Pope spends last hours surrounded by cardinals who stand glaring at him with folded arms, silently reminding him of the political necessity of clinging to life.

23.Doctors examining the body discover that the Pope was not only a woman, but also Hitler.

22.Mankind scrambles to choose new leader of inflexible, sexually morbid institutional anachronism; heretofore anonymous bureaucrat will instantly be celebrated as world's holiest man as he travels to AIDS-stricken Africa to denounce the use of condoms.

21.Telltale white smoke emitting from Vatican chimneys announces a) choice of new Pope, and b) the fiery death of the 5000 back issues of Manscape and Hung Inches that had accumulated in the Vatican lobby.

20.Hall and Oates mulling comeback.

19.To the end, the Pope could only think of the poor and the downtrodden.

18.When he died, he stopped thinking of the poor and the downtrodden, and his face was frozen in that baboon smile, and he thought of nothing at all.

17.In his last days, the Pope was in tremendous pain.

16.NBC Nightly News intern pulls wrong tape from drawer full of long-ago archived video obits; world thinks Boris Yeltsin has died, wonders why Brian Williams is calling him an "inspirational spiritual leader."

15.Williams, after broadcast: "Who's Boris Yeltsin?"

14.Matt Lauer to Williams: "He wrote the Contract for America."

13.Just before death, Pope sits up in his bed, shrieks, his body bursts into flames; everyone runs from the room.

12.Sequoia, birch, maple, willow, palm, oak, pine, fir, maple?No, wait, I said maple already...

11.Hello my baby, hello my honey, hello my ragtime gal...

10.You dirty rat. You dirty, double-crossing rat... Proxima estacion: Tibidabo. Tenga cuidado de las puertas deslizantes... It means woods and blanche means white, so the two together mean white woods... L'ø~t? c'est moi! Don't think about eels, don't think about eels...

9.Bush on the tragic event: "Our thoughts and prayers go out to this great man and all of his many children."

8.Bush continued: "He touched all of us in places no one else could reach."

7. According to ancient tradition, the slamming shut of the Bronze Door in St. Peter's Square announces the death of the Pope.

6.Normal Vatican schedule closes that door at 8 p.m. every night and reopens it in the morning.

5.According to numerous reports, if the Pope dies at night this time, no one will know what to do. (This is not a joke.)

4.In 1958, reporters paid off Pope Pius XII's physician to throw open the hospital room window when the Pope died.

3.When a monsignor threw the window open to get some air, the Pope's death was erroneously reported all over the world.

2.This is what happens when weird old men in dresses communicate with the world with doors and chimneys.

1.Throw a marble at the dead Pope's head. Bonk!

Posted by Amy Welborn | Permalink

Comments

Please pray for Mr. Taibbi and his associates.

Posted by: Cranky Lawyer at Mar 4, 2005 11:06:21 AM

I think this newspaper is one of those hip, city "freebies" that people read on the subway. As Fr. Bryce Sibley mentioned on his blog the other day, this little man is in for a real chuckle if the next Pope turns out to be a more forceful disciplinarian than John Paul.

Posted by: Rich Leonardi at Mar 4, 2005 11:14:14 AM

Taibbi and Bill O'Reilly were schooled in "New England TV journalism" in Providence and Boston respectively. It's characterized by smart-ass know-it-allism, fancies itself as highly intellectual, relies for insights on faculty members from one of the area's "approved institutions of higher learning", and depends on the conceit that the point of view is considerably more important than the facts of the story. That such an approach to reality attracts wide audiences says volumes about the state of our society.

Posted by: Dan Crawford at Mar 4, 2005 11:21:12 AM

I don't understand how he can say these things about another human being - any human being.

If Matt had said in once sentence, "I'll be glad when the pope is dead because I don't like him" - then I'd understand. He's entitled to his opinion. But this???? You're right, Amy. It's insane. not sane.

Ugh.

Posted by: Meggan at Mar 4, 2005 11:22:32 AM

What a surprise. They don't like us. If this is how they feel about our spiritual leader. Odd that this piece of (this is a family blog) has generated angry words from people like Hillary Clinton and Chuck Schumer. Talk about the enemy of my enemy is my friend. At least in this instance. So now you wonder why there's a Catholic League and a feisty guy like Bill Donoghue in charge....

Posted by: Gerard E. at Mar 4, 2005 11:28:35 AM

substitute the pope with some head of a muslim community (sorry, not familiar with terms) and watch the outrage.

Posted by: cathy at Mar 4, 2005 11:29:52 AM

Taibbi is only saying things the vast majority of those in the media and entertainment industry wish they could say. I worked in the news media, very anti-Catholic. Things that would come out of people's mouths in reference to Catholicism that would get them fired if it was directed at jews/blacks/homosexuals/etc.

The media will tolerate mamby-pamby John Kerry Catholics, the ones who toe the liberal cultural line. However, the hatred against the true Church is very real.

The media hates us, it's not being paranoid or accusatory, but the real deal.

"If the world hates you, remember, it hated me first."

Posted by: Edward T. at Mar 4, 2005 11:33:35 AM

I admit it! I confess sometimes I've been known to laugh at an insensitive evil joke, sometimes. I'm not proud of it. That having been said none of this crap is EVEN FUNNY!
Yes I agree with Amy these "jokes" are pathological, insane,...etc. But they AREN'T even funny! I'm reminded of the old Middle Eastern say "If you are going to go to Hell for adultery. At least make sure it's not for an ugly woman."
To sum up. This fellow is a low life. But to add insult to injury he isn't even a funny low life.

Posted by: BenYachov(Jim Scott 4th) at Mar 4, 2005 11:35:28 AM

I don't know how Matt Taibi contrived to enter my house last night, but the fact is evident. I found his heart in my cat's litter box this morning.

Posted by: Hunk Hondo at Mar 4, 2005 11:40:19 AM

Oh, I don't know, I think #26 is a scream, myself. Otherwise I agree w/Edward T.; keep this in mind and never forget it. They often pay us lip service but underneath, yeah, there is that much vitriol and hatred.

Posted by: KH at Mar 4, 2005 11:47:21 AM

Oh, I don't know, I think #26 is a scream, myself. Otherwise I agree w/Edward T.; keep this in mind and never forget it. They often pay us lip service but underneath, yeah, there is that much vitriol and hatred.

Posted by: KH at Mar 4, 2005 11:47:21 AM

The deeper issue for me is not what it says to "us" as Catholics, but as "us" as human beings. And here Meggan and Hunk Hondo get it right - the worldview is disturbing, not because of prejudice against Catholics, but because of the attitude towards a real human being who is suffering.

It's scary.

Posted by: amy at Mar 4, 2005 11:58:54 AM

One has to have touched a nerve to bring forth a response like this piece of trash.I strongly suspect that the Pope has touched this nerve sometime in the writer`s past.

Posted by: Paul at Mar 4, 2005 12:31:14 PM

I really, really, really hope Hall & Oates aren't contemplating a comeback.

Posted by: ajb at Mar 4, 2005 12:35:40 PM

This is a sign that American society passed a terrible point of no return some time ago. Yeah, this guy wrote it, but SOMEONE PUBLISHED IT. Screams of outrage only serve to convince them that they have succeeded in whatever they were trying to do.

Jesus died for these dudes. I have to keep reminding myself of that.

Posted by: Roz at Mar 4, 2005 12:38:55 PM

Fr. Sibley had this up a couple days ago. I second his and Rich's comments about how funny it will be for these folks if the next Pope turns out to *really* conservative.

Haven't been able to access their site since. Looks like they crashed themselves with this story. Talk about unintended blessings.

The article itself is execrable in ways which defy adequate description. It's Elephant Dung Mary, only in writing.

Blue State secular culture at its worst. No question. Surely there are classier ways to up your readership. Like, say, having the editors set themselves on fire outside the front door.

Posted by: Richard at Mar 4, 2005 12:55:06 PM

I realize that even to ask this confers a kind of legitimacy on this articled it doesn't deserve. But is he correct (in 7,6, and 5) about shutting the Bronze Door when a pope dies? Is he talking about the main doors to the Basilica? Those are only open for Holy Years and Easter no? And there are no gates to St. Peter square. I mean I lived in Rome for a semester and don't remember that.

Posted by: piraeus at Mar 4, 2005 12:56:24 PM

Quick, someone send this clown a copy of anything written by Mark Twain. If you are going to attempt humor writing, it is very important to have something at least mildly amusing in it. This tripe even fails as anti-Catholic literature; Martin Luther would shake his head at this sorry attempt at pope hatred. We desperately need more literate anti-Catholics who will produce something worth responding to. This sorry mess isn't even on a par with some poor addled bag lady screeching that the Pope is the anti-Christ outside of a Church.

Posted by: Donald R. McClarey at Mar 4, 2005 1:08:14 PM

"One has to have touched a nerve to bring forth a response like this piece of trash.I strongly suspect that the Pope has touched this nerve sometime in the writer`s past."

The only other time I have witnessed virulent anti-John Paul II sentiments (though not quite this bad) was during a conversation I had with a homosexual former religious.

I have been told that a former priest at my parish (before the arrival of our current very orthodox priest) used to fly into fits of apoplexy at the very mention of the name John Paul II.

Posted by: Jay Anderson at Mar 4, 2005 1:18:57 PM

Vile.despicable,cruel,dishonest,abominable,vitriole,
the product of a diseased mind with no forgiveable qualities,debasing,insulting,sacriligeous,scurrilous,beyond all bounds of any humor or crirticism, fiendish,absurd,sophomoric, hate-filled and depressing, calculated to appeal to morons who feed and thrive on this kind of defecation .
And you say that this is a strong under-current in the fourth estate? It is proof of how tough it is to be #1.

Posted by: Tom Kelty at Mar 4, 2005 1:23:08 PM

Is this for real?

Posted by: RP Burke at Mar 4, 2005 1:35:40 PM

In ascending order by level of horror and dismay invoked:

--that somebody would think some of these thoughts

--that he would think they are funny

--that he would think other people would think they are funny

--that he would be right

--that a newspaper, no matter how "alternative," would consider them fit to publish

In point of fact, I don't think "funny" is really the operative word. The sort of glee in evidence here has nothing to do with humor in the normal sense, but rather with the imagined consummation of an enormous hatred.

Posted by: Maclin Horton at Mar 4, 2005 2:09:05 PM

If he were to be consistent, Taibbi would write a whole series of "52 Funniest Things" about other deaths and tragedies past, present, and future as well.

For example:

"The 52 Funniest Things About the Death of Martin Luther King, Jr." or,

"The 52 Funniest Things About the Death of the Dalai Lama," or

"The 52 Funniest Things About FDR's Polio," or

"The 52 Funniest Things About AIDS," or

"The 52 Funniest Things About the Holocaust"

As you can see, the possibilities for similar such "comedy" are endless.

Of course, if he were to do such a thing you'd never hear the end of the screeching emanating from the outraged and offended.

Posted by: John M.Esparolini at Mar 4, 2005 2:12:46 PM

Jesus saw THIS at Gethsemane, too..

I spoze the thing to do (ok, prayer, fasting, stations of the cross) --- but the thing to DO, politically, is to deprive them of every one of their advertisers.

Where's the list? Who's got the list? Where do I write? Where do I call?

Posted by: Julianne Wiley at Mar 4, 2005 2:30:10 PM

Where do I call?

Get the Catholic League on this, if they aren't already.

Posted by: Rick at Mar 4, 2005 2:36:06 PM

Post a comment