« Post-Mortem | Main | Remember the Study? »

November 09, 2005

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451be0d69e200d834967c3a69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Books, Books,Books:

Comments

Vivian

I dont quite get the cover of the Pope making google eyes or something, is he saying he is bad or something? I am confused

Maclin Horton

I'm going to have to read Zmirak's book. That recent Godspy piece in which he recounted his adolescent fear that he himself was the anti-Christ was very funny.

Yeah, Catholics live on the edge of good taste--and frequently fall over.

Lickona

Amen, Maclin - St. Catherine of Siena, drinking the discharge from a person's wound? Bad, bad taste. And yet the woman is a Doctor of the Church. The Church is the original carnival.

Vivian - I think the idea of the cover photo is that even serious Catholicism (embodied by the pope) allows plenty of room for the odd, the mysterious, and the irreverent (toward the right objects).

Ed

Bad taste, yes. And it has happened over many centuries. If memory serves correctly,Will Durant's multi-volume "History of Civilization" mentioned that several cathedrals in medieval Europe all claimed they had the head of John the Baptist. Another cathedral, church, or monastery, claimed it had the only relic of Christ's circumcision.

Good taste has always been at risk in the Church. It's unfortunate those times when truth took a beating as well.

Jeff

Vivian:

I remember the picture. The Pope was just playing around--I think there were some kids about or something.

mfundis

Bought it, LOVED IT. My daughter thought I was nuts, sitting in the corner of my den cracking up- being Catholic is SO cool as I tell my jr high catechism class!

Roberto

What about that request in REALLY bad taste that we eat Jesus' body? Enough to send away even well meaning disciples, then as now.

Good thing Jesus went on to explain that he was just kidding... Oh wait: He didn't! Maybe I should read this book!

rcesq

I've had that picture of John Paul on my refrigerator for years. He's looking back at a crowd that's armed with binoculars and cameras. And "good taste" is what's made contemporary church architecture look like Pottery Barn. Give me that old time religion with plaster statues, St. Anthony's larynx, and lace doilies on everything and everyone.

Anne

I'm 21 and go to a very secular university, but fortunately I have quite a few hardcore Catholic friends and we sort of make our own Catholic fun. For the feast day of the Beheading of St. John the Baptist we made a cake that looked like a head and put it on a silver platter and before eating it read the Gospel account of the beheading. For All Souls Day we went to the Catholic Cemetary at night armed with a jug of holy water and prayer books and essentially tried to get as many souls out of purgatory as possible (while also critiquing the use (or lack thereof) of saints and other Catholic things on gravestones). So...basically, I think this book sounds real cool and definately captures what is so awesome about Holy Mother Church.

Maggie

If we can't laugh lovingly at ourselves we have lost something.

I give a religious book to each of my kids each year this year I will be giving this to my devoted husband for Christmas.

Nicole

Just picked it up at Borders. Hilarious so far.

Nicole

Matthew

I can't stand these type of books that demean and trivialize Catholicism.

Nicole

Matthew, just curious, have you read it? To me it does anything but. Nicole

Matthew

I leafed through it at the local Barnes and Noble, it was placed near the book, Catholicism for Dummies. I am more traditional in nature, and I feel that 'mainstreaming' the Catholic faith only brings it down to the level of Protestantism.

Granted I did not see an Imprimatur, I see no reason to help this person profit on something that is basically a cartoon version of the Catechism.

John Zmirak

Dear Matthew,
Just by way of explanation--the book is MEANT to look as if it might be a slam at the Church by a burned out ex-believer...because we want to sell the books to those people. When they pick it up, they will indeed laugh (no false advertising there!) but WITH the Church, not at Her. Along the way, they'll get completely orthodox explanations of the Sacraments, Humanae Vitae, and other controversial Church teachings... along with a strong dose of Catholic history and apologetics. But laughter (and the "Bad Catholic" persona) help lower the barriers which lapsed Catholics put up against the Truth. At least, that's our hope, as authors!
God bless,
John

Nicole

John, I think it's awesome. I am glad to have a way to learn about the Saints and I was excited to see you mentioning two of my favorite authors Greg Popcak and Christopher West. I am learning a lot already and my husband and I have been laughing our heads off.

I sure wish I'd thought of it!
Nicole

John Zmirak

Thanks, Nicole! I'm hoping that wiseacre disaffected Catholics buy the book as a gift for the pious relatives; and vice-versa!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.